On a plant project the P&ID is the language of the process team, and the 3D model is the language of piping, structural and the other disciplines. Both describe the same plant: the same equipment, lines and valves.
Yet in many teams they are made in different tools and kept in separate files. The same information has to be entered twice, and someone has to keep checking that the two still match.
The trouble with two sources of data
Every P&ID revision has to be carried over to the model by hand. Line and valve lists are often kept in their own spreadsheets. As long as the data lives in several places, small differences slip through until review, or later.
- A line number or size on the P&ID differs from the 3D model
- A valve on the P&ID hasn't been modeled in 3D yet
- The line list wasn't updated after a P&ID revision
What one plant data model means
In one plant data model every piece of equipment, line, valve and instrument is a data object, not just lines on a drawing. The P&ID and the 3D model become two views of the same objects.
In Brilian 3D a line that touches equipment creates and links the nozzle automatically. The line number fills in size, class and fluid. Equipment, line and valve lists are generated from the P&ID, so they always match the drawing.
From P&ID to 3D without retyping
Since the data is already there, piping engineers don't retype the P&ID. Brilian 3D can place all the equipment and route all the lines straight from the P&ID, following project rules such as slope, elbow angles and clearance with insulation.
A P&ID-to-3D cross-check then shows where the two still differ, so differences are found during design, not after drawings are issued.
Collaborating on the same data
One plant data model also means the process and piping teams can work at the same time. Changes appear right away for everyone on the project. Objects being worked on are claimed, per sheet for P&IDs, so no one overwrites anyone else's work.
Questions to ask when choosing a tool
If your team is evaluating plant design tools, these questions show whether P&IDs and 3D really share data:
- Is the P&ID stored as data, or only as a drawing?
- Are line and valve lists generated from the P&ID?
- Can 3D routing take lines straight from the P&ID?
- Is there an automatic check between the P&ID and the 3D model?
- Can several engineers work at once without sending files?
- Can the data be exchanged through open formats such as DEXPI?